| Draft_2023 | Player | |
| 1 | Elon Musk | Matt Mervis |
| 2 | Nomads | Termarr Johnson |
| 3 | Bohm Squad | Jackson Chourio |
| 4 | Belly Ups | Carson Williams |
| 5 | Open Lakemonsters | Druw Jones |
| 6 | Kaniption fit | Masataka Yoshida |
| 7 | Mr. Lotz's Class from Bronx Bombers | Jackson Holliday |
| 8 | Open baseball Crunch | Elijah Green |
| 9 | Fear the Turtle | Kyle Manzardo |
| 10 | Bay Birds | Oscar Colas |
| 11 | Mice | Ezequiel Tovar |
| 12 | Mr. Lotz's class | Jackson Merrill |
| 13 | Ofer Hofer | Endy Rodriguez |
| 14 | Mr. Lotz's class from Jay's expert team | Cam Collier |
| 15 | Scorpions | Emmanuel Rodriguez |
| 16 | Bad Boys | Alex DeJesus |
| 2nd Round | ||
| 1 | Elon Musk | Kevin Parada |
| 2 | Nomads | Brooks Lee |
| 3 | Bohm Squad | Jace Jung |
| 4 | Belly Ups | Evan Carter |
| 5 | Open Lakemonsters | Zach Neto |
| 6 | Kaniption fit | Gavin Cross |
| 7 | Bronx Bombers | Connor Norby |
| 8 | Open baseball Crunch | Adael Amador |
| 9 | Fear the Turtle | Ceddanne Rafaela |
| 10 | Bay Birds | Christian Encarnacion-Strand |
| 11 | Mice-Nomads | Jacob Berry |
| 12 | Mr. Lotz's class | Deyvison De Los Santos |
| 13 | Ofer Hofer-Lotz | Junior Caminero |
| 14 | Jay's expert team | Masyn Winn |
| 15 | Scorpions | Spencer Jones |
| 16 | Bad Boys | Addison Barger |
| 3rd Round | Player | |
| 1 | Elon Musk | Jordan Diaz |
| 2 | Nomads | Chase DeLauter |
| 3 | Bohm Squad | Edwin Arroyo |
| 4 | Belly Ups | Miguel Bleis |
| 5 | Open Lakemonsters | Drew Gilbert |
| 6 | Kaniption fit | Jake Alu |
| 7 | Bronx Bombers | Xavier Isaac |
| 8 | Open baseball Crunch | Alex Ramirez |
| 9 | Fear the Turtle | Roderick Arias |
| 10 | Bay Birds | Joey Wiemer |
| 11 | Mice | Cade Marlowe |
| 12 | Mr. Lotz's class | Edouard Julien |
| 13 | Ofer Hofer | Jose Ramos |
| 14 | Jay's expert team | |
| 15 | Scorpions | Bryan Ramos |
| 16 | Bad Boys | Austin Wells |